The Darkness in Harry Potter’s World

By Amanda Pizzolatto (Rated G)

We both entered the house ecstatically, both of us fascinated by the idea of a haunted house. What would we find there, what would we see and feel? Would we get any particular kind of activity? Would we get any activity at all? We walked through the house and down into the basement, a cozy den complete with a sofa, a couple of recliners, a couple of tables for games, and a record player. I began to feel uneasy, something wasn’t right and the sense that something evil lurked in the room came over me. I turned to my partner, none other than Harry Potter himself, and tried to voice my concerns, but no sound came out. He wasn’t paying attention to me anymore, something else held that. I didn’t know what caught his attention, until I heard a heavy breathing. The sofa had begun to move, going in and out, in time to the breathing sounds I heard. The recliners soon joined in, followed by the turning of the record player as it began to jump around a haunting scramble of the record, revealing evil gibberish and laughter. The sense that something evil had arrived and was planning on hurting us grew, and I cried out that we needed to leave, but again, Harry paid me no mind. Instead he walked towards the possessed objects as if he too was possessed. I wanted to tear him away, but both my body and a voice in my head told me to run. I did run, and I didn’t look back until I was across the street from the house. There, my dream ended, but not before I knew that the house fell in on itself, taking everyone who was inside with it. 

Yes, my dear readers, it was just a dream. I’m sure many of you hate such openings, but it seemed the best way to start this. At the time, though, I did think it was merely Harry Potter as he was played by Daniel Radcliffe who was in my dream for I never truly saw his face, I only know by instinct that it was. As it has been in many such dreams, for even Frodo has visited me, but his presence has been much sweeter and kinder than that one time Harry came. Of course, I do also know that I dreamt it due to a previous conversation with a good friend’s mother who had forbade Harry Potter to her children as it reminded her far too much of her experiences with witchcraft. I cannot say more for I promised to keep the rest a secret, but I can say this, the experience scared her, and that Harry Potter’s world reminded her so much of it, that it worried both her and me. However, years down the road, I felt that I was both brave and strong enough to face such a threat, especially now that many other friends had deemed it safe. I enjoy a good story, so what could I say? Maybe it wasn’t as all bad as many others made it out to be, maybe they were reading too much into it, like some people like to do with Lord of the Rings and Chronicles of Narnia. So, I decided to give it a go. I will say this, Rowling is a pretty good author, but by the third book, things were starting to get darker, and for some reason, so was my eyesight. No, I am serious, I must notice anything that goes on with my eyes because I have many problems with my eyes, and for this to suddenly occur, it worried me. I decided then and there that I would not read the rest of the books, but I wanted to know what happened next, and eventually watched the movies. That’s when things really started to bother me. What was it with these movies and showing a colorless world? It irked me to no end for I truly enjoy a good splash of color. And what worried me even more was that I was perfectly fine with any old Batman movie, but Harry Potter? Get me to Oz, Neverland, or Narnia quick, or I’d die of Color Loss Syndrome (I know, I made that up, be quiet). It really did feel like all color was being sucked out of me. What in the world was going on? 

I have always had a fascination with color and symbolism, so to see a practical lack of it, at least color, in Harry Potter’s world really drove me nuts. I will say this, though I will never be able to take her seriously because her initials are J.K., Rowling has at least gotten me fired up to fill my world completely with colors and scents, so much so, that I probably really dipped my toes into fanfiction simply because I wanted to go around Hogwarts and graffiti it, just to add some color. I seriously would think about what colors would look good in those dreary halls filled with children. That was half of what I thought during those movies, if not the majority of it – those halls were so boring, so dreary that you wonder how in the world it became a great place for children. There seemed to be no light, hence, no colors, and if there were any, it was mostly muted. Previous children’s classics, like Alice in Wonderland and the Neverending Story, had worlds full of colors, scents, and sounds as well as a sense of wonder at the world around us. In Harry Potter, there doesn’t seem to be any wonder, any of the real magic of childhood, it seems more like Harry is simply being primed and readied like a soldier to defeat Voldemort (gasps . . . I said it! Wow, he’s boring too). Heck, even that glorious light in the sky, our greatest defender against the nightmares and horrors of the night, the sun, is barely seen in Harry Potter. And the more I watched, the more I noticed that everything takes place on a cloudy day or in the darkest of the night. Having had a Film & Literature class that delved somewhat into themes and symbolism, I began to wonder what the lack of sunlight meant because it was certainly no means a typical England day (they get more sun than that). Was Rowling hiding something, and that if the sun shone on her magical world, it would melt away like the Wicked Witch of the West? Of course I have heard of the theory (that almost seems like fact now) that she wrote Harry Potter as a “revenge story” against her chemistry teacher. Was that the light that she was trying to hide? But the more I thought about it, the less likely that seemed, though it did seem to be a part of it. Then what? What could it be? Could it actually be because she was in fact pulling from real witchcraft, a very, very dangerous past time? If many knew about that, then yes, many parents would have every right to fear for their children. The devil is no mere boogeyman under the bed, he means to do real harm. But was that really the answer? To be honest, I really can’t say, I have only watched the Harry Potter movies once and have only read the first three books. Perhaps it’s more evident in later books? Perhaps I would notice it if I watched it again and keep my eyes peeled for it? Quite possibly, but I shall never return to find out. Once was perhaps too much for me for, unlike some people, I need a world full of color. Though, I guess you could say one good thing did come from this, I have never been so grateful for color and worlds like Oz, Narnia, and Neverland in my entire life. So thank you Rowling, at least for that, but as I mentioned before, Hogwarts is not a place I would ever return to again. 

Image from

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s