By Lyn Bennett Wilson
Find the rest of the story here!
The morning air in Applefield was sharp enough to sting, but Bob Schlagel Jr. didn’t feel the cold. He was whistling as he walked toward the jeweler’s on Main Street, He had known Lillian Hyde since the earth’s crust was forming—or at least since eighth grade—but for the last two weeks, he’d been seeing her through the lens of a “forever” he hadn’t quite dared to vocalize yet.
Inside Garrety’s, the old jeweler stepped out from the back with a velvet box that seemed to vibrate with significance.
“It’s a masterpiece, Mr. G,” Bob whispered as the lid snapped open.
The engagement ring was a bridge between generations: a gold band holding a round-cut ruby, surrounded by the delicate pearls from Bob’s grandmother’s ring. The wedding band was wider, modern yet timeless, inset with his grandmother’s opal.
“Lillian doesn’t wear rings in the bakery, obviously,” Mr. Garrety said, sliding a small clear loop across the counter. “But I’ve included one of my patented silicone ring protectors. It’ll keep the band snug even if her hands are covered in flour.”
“She hasn’t said yes yet, Mr. G,” Bob grinned, tucking the box safely away. “But tomorrow’s the night.”
Across the street at Ginny’s Cookie Jar, the atmosphere was less “romantic” and more “combustion engine.” Lillian Hyde was hovering over a tray of pecan sweet rolls, her brow furrowed in a look of scrupulous intensity.
“Bethann, the dinner rolls?” Lillian called out.
“Cooling and waiting to be boxed, Lilli!” came the cheery reply from the shop.
Lillian checked her list. The Progressive Christmas Eve Dinner for the First Lutheran Church was the event of the year. Feeding eighteen members of church leadership across four different Victorian homes was a logistical nightmare. It required moving vans, specialized shelving, and the kind of temperature control that usually required a laboratory.
“Ancient kitchens,” Lillian muttered, grabbing her gear and her loyal alert dog, Pumpkin Pie. “Aunt Pauline, you told me those kitchens were ‘modern’ once.”
“They were!” Pauline barked back with a laugh. “In 1920!”
The evening began in a flurry of puff pastries and the precise movements of a silent drill team. Nathan Kubelsky, the head caterer of this event, had organized the kitchens with the precision of a field medic, marking off the gluten-free zones with surgical tape. While Nathan was a bit “loud” in his commands, his efficiency was undeniable. The Kubelsky team handled the heavy lifting of the main courses—sturdy meat and potato dishes that anchored the meal.
To ensure the highest safety standards for the main event, the church had contracted Flatville Turkey Farms. Known for their impeccable local reputation, Flatville provided the specialized gluten-free main courses, ensuring that even the most sensitive diners could eat without fear. Lillian didn’t usually serve full meals, but for tonight, she had prepared a series of specialized, silky soups to accompany her hand-shaped gluten-free breads.
Because of the strict sanitary protocols and the chaotic “shark-like” movements of the staff, Lillian had set up Pumpkin Pie’s travel crate just inside the kitchen doorway. It was a mesh-sided pop-up kennel that allowed Punkin to stay in her “safe zone,” out of the way of heavy trays, while still being able to smell and see Lillian to monitor her heart rate.
Bob was there, working the stove at the first house, his dimples flashing every time Lillian walked past. He had the ring in his pocket. He tried to corner her in the parlor, the ruby burning a hole in his trousers, when the first obstacle appeared: Tony Bartolomo.
Tony, the former food critic turned car-hire driver, wandered into the room wearing a hat that blinked with garish Christmas lights. He proceeded to tell a string of jokes so unfunny the room seemed to drop five degrees.
However, the distraction didn’t last long, as the rave reviews began to pour in from the dining room. Diners who were normally apprehensive about “alternative” baking were stunned by the texture of Lillian’s rolls. “You’d never know,” was the refrain of the night—the highest compliment a gluten-free baker can receive. Between the Flatville turkey and Lillian’s artistry, the church leadership was in culinary heaven.
At the second stop—the Linoak County Historical Society—the lights went out. A microwave and a warming tray had a disagreement with the 19th-century wiring, resulting in an “almighty pop” and a smell of ozone. In the blue-flicker of battery-operated candles, the temperature in the cramped genealogy room soared.
Pumpkin Pie began scratching at the mesh of her crate, letting out a sharp, rhythmic alert bark. Bob didn’t need to ask. He saw the way Lillian’s hand went to the mahogany bookshelf for support and the specific, alarming crimson climbing her neck.
Without a word, Bob was at her side. He didn’t ask if she was “fine”—he knew better. He slipped an arm around her waist, shepherding her away from the heat of the dead appliances and toward a heavy velvet chair in the corner. He pressed her down gently into the seat and, within seconds, was back with a glass of water and a cold, damp cloth he’d scavenged from the service bar.
Lillian leaned her head back, her eyes closed as the “blackhawk” helicopter thrummed in her chest and the gray edges of her vision threatened to close in. Words weren’t necessary; she squeezed his hand to thank him. He borrowed a hand fan from the gift shop, and Lillian fanned her face and neck until the room stopped its slow, nauseating tilt.
In the dim light, the Pastor of the Lutheran church sensed the rising panic of the hosts. He stood in the center of the dark room and raised his hands. “Friends, a little darkness cannot dim our fellowship. Let us offer a word of prayer for this meal and for the hands that prepared it.”
The prayer acted as a grounding wire for the whole room. The Amens echoed through the room’s vaulted ceiling. There was a moment of silence before everyone began to move toward the door for the next course.
The Church Treasurer pulled Bob and Lillian aside in the quiet of the cooling room. With a warm handshake and a word of deep thanks for their poise during the outage, he handed them each their respective checks in payment for their supplies and excellent service.
With the logistics settled, the decision was made: the second course—a delicate winter squash soup and garden greens—would be packed up and served alongside the main course at the next stop.
“Moving on!” Nathan’s voice boomed. “We’re merging the courses at the Elks Lodge!”
“Go,” Lillian managed to whisper, her hand trembling as she took the water from Bob’s hand. “I’ve got this,” she smiled up at him. She wasn’t sure whether to be impressed or a little unnerved by how well he knew her. They had only been a “formal” couple for a few weeks.
“I’m not leaving until your color comes back, Lil,” Bob said, his voice quiet and firm, ignoring the bustle of the staff packing the soup tureens into the van. Pumpkin Pie, now released from the crate, sat firmly on Lillian’s feet, adding her own weight to the grounding process.
By the time they reached the final “dessert” stop at the Engineer’s House—a massive Victorian fortress of silent floorboards and perfect ninety-degree angles—Bob was what Lillian called “a long-tailed cat in a room full of rocking chairs.” He spent the rest of the night scanning her face for the next flush, his hyper-vigilance clashing with Lillian’s fierce, lifelong streak of independence. She’d been navigating the world on her own terms since she was four years old and certainly didn’t want anyone making a “fuss.” To ensure her safety without the restriction of the crate, Lillian decided Pumpkin Pie would remain at her heels for the rest of the service, the portable kennel packed away in favor of active, silent monitoring.
The drive home in Bob’s yellow Corvette was the first moment of true silence they’ve had all night. The heaters were turned down low at Lillian’s request, the cool air from the cracked window acting as a tonic.
“Aunt Pauline says I look like a white cat in a snowstorm,” Lillian laughed softly, leaning her head against the seat as the color finally began to return to normal. “I’m absolutely spent, Bob. That last kitchen was a furnace.”
“Let me just walk you in,” Bob said as they pulled into her driveway. “CeCe, who drove the catering truck, already dropped Pumpkin Pie off.”
Inside the kitchen, the electric teapot began to hiss, sending a plume of steam into the air. Lillian turned around to ask about Earl Grey, but the words died in her throat.
Bob was down on one knee on the linoleum. Pumpkin Pie was sitting right next to him, looking as solemn as a judge.
“Lillian Hyde,” Bob said, his voice thick and cracking. “I have loved you since the moment I clapped eyes on your freckled face and ponytails in the eighth grade. Will you do me the honor of being my wife?”
Lillian stood frozen. She looked at the man who had been her friend since the “earth’s crust was forming”—the man who had spent the last three hours watching her heart rate more closely than the appetizers. She looked at the ruby ring, the pearls, and the dog who was watching her with expectant eyes.
“Bob,” she whispered, that breathless feeling finally making sense. “Of course, I will.”
As he slipped the ruby onto her finger—the silicone protector keeping it perfectly snug—the “scrupulous” baker and the “Super Bob” of Applefield finally stopped running. For the first time all night, the “quiet frequency” of the town was replaced by the simple, steady sound of two people finally coming home.
Miss an earlier part? Find it here!
LogoSophia Magazine 